Every fall, I get calls from people trying to make sense of what is happening with prices on the Jersey Shore. Some are thinking about selling, some are thinking about rightsizing, and some are just wondering whether to wait. Here is what the most recent numbers show for the two counties I work in every day.
Ocean County: steady prices and more choices
The latest county data puts Ocean County's median home sale price right around $500,000, according to Zillow's market data through September 30, 2026. The county's typical home value was about $551,000, roughly 4.8 percent higher than a year earlier. A separate Q3 2026 market report from the area's MLS put the median closed sale at $510,000, about 2 percent above the same quarter of 2025.
Realtor.com showed a median listing price near $527,000 across roughly 4,700 homes for sale in the county in late September. More homes on the market than in recent years means buyers have more to compare, and sellers have to price carefully rather than assume bidding wars.
Monmouth County: stronger price growth
Monmouth County told a different story this fall. The New Jersey REALTORS Local Market Update put the median single-family sale price at about $849,900 in October 2026, up 8.3 percent from roughly $785,000 a year earlier. Year to date, the county's median single-family sale price was about $844,450, compared with $784,000 over the same period in 2025.
Much of that growth sits in the higher end. Zillow put Monmouth County's typical home value at about $790,000 at the end of October, up 7.5 percent year over year. Spring Lake's median home value reached about $1.52 million in September, roughly 17 percent above the year before, according to Zillow's market data.
What the towns in between look like
County averages hide a lot of variety, and the town-level numbers from Q1 2026 local market analysis show why. Toms River's median closed sale was about $513,000. Brick's median list price was about $520,000, up about 6.8 percent year over year. Manchester's median list price was about $280,000, up about 10 percent. Point Pleasant's average home value was about $769,000 as of August 2026, up 10.3 percent from a year earlier.
Days on market matter too. Homes in Brick were spending about 33 days on the market in early 2026, while homes in Toms River were spending about 58. Waterfront properties are drawing more buyer scrutiny around insurance, elevation, and flood compliance, while updated, correctly priced 55-plus and adult-community homes continue to sell steadily.
What this means for your decision
For sellers, buyers have more choices than they did a couple of years ago, so pricing and preparation matter more than they used to. For rightsizers, this is a good moment to see what your current home would bring and what your next chapter would cost; the gap between the two is what decides timing. For buyers, more inventory and steadier prices in Ocean County mean there is less pressure to rush.
Numbers are a snapshot, not a prediction. If you would like the latest figures for your own neighborhood or the town you are considering, I can pull current data for the address and walk you through what it means. Let's figure this out together.
Sources: Zillow market data (Ocean County through September 30, 2026; Monmouth County through October 31, 2026; Point Pleasant August 2026; Spring Lake September 2026), the New Jersey REALTORS Local Market Update for Monmouth County (October 2026), Realtor.com (September 30, 2026), and Q1 2026 town-level analysis of MLS data. Markets move; confirm the latest numbers when you are ready to act.
Written by
Lori Eipel
Broker Associate with Keller Williams Spring Lake, helping rightsizers, sellers, and buyers across Monmouth and Ocean Counties, New Jersey for nine years.
More about Lori